Friday mystery object #45 answer


On Friday, whilst I was in the lovely friendly town of Portaferry catching up with some old friends,  I gave you this mystery object to identify:

Unfortunately my phone seemed reticent to work properly, making it hard to respond to everyone’s questions, so thanks to Debi Linton for fielding some of the questions/suggestions. This object is one of those that is so characteristic in its structure that once you’ve seen one you will probably be able to spot another with ease, even though they have a huge variety of shapes, as pointed out by Benjamin Brooks in his comment (which provides a link to an image hosted by the Oceans of Kansas Paleontology site who incidentally have a mystery object of their own).

If you click on the image I provided you’ll see more detail, which makes it very clear that this is something composed of interlocking units that look like shiny bone. Shiny bone (that looks like a piece of ceramic) usually means bone with an enamel layer, which usually means teeth. These teeth are arrayed in a plate and if you look at the top of the plate you’ll see that it is discoloured, pitted and well worn. Clearly only this top part of the plate has seen much use and that use has been heavy, given the wear.

So why have all the rest of the tooth plate if it isn’t being used? Of course, the rest of the plate will be used, it just hasn’t moved into position yet – so what animal has teeth that move like a conveyor belt and are constantly being replaced? Sharks are the first things to come to my mind, but they don’t tend to have big flat plates, so think of something related to sharks that might need big flat plates for crushing something that very hard, probably marine molluscs.

If you haven’t worked it out already, this is a tooth plate from a ray – in fact this one is from one of the cownose rays, probably Rhinoptera bonasus (Mitchil, 1815) based on the seven series of teeth. There is an excellent description of the cownose ray by the Florida Museum of Natural History if you want to know more.

Finally I’d like to congratulate everyone who had worked out that this was a ray tooth plate and who dropped hints rather than give it away – the powerpack for Dan Dare’s raygun by Dave Godfrey was nice and I liked Robert Grant‘s You are all Batty, which is a nice reference to the Batoidea, the group of cartilaginous fish that contains the rays. I must admit that Tim JonesFishes with piles has left me puzzled, but I expect that’s more to do with my mental state after only arriving back from Northern Ireland in the small hours of the morning.

3 thoughts on “Friday mystery object #45 answer

  1. Fascinating, and what a nice community of knowledgeable people to drop hints for those of us without a clue. I shall be trying to work out Fishes with piles myself now I know the answer to the FMO, there being various meanings of piles ….

    I managed to miss your earlier post on Back from extinction. That was really interesting, sorry I missed the event. You need to tell us – if not me, then the Applied Scientists – so we can publicise to our students

  2. Thanks to Dave Godfrey, I now know there is such a thing as an eagle ray – I followed a hunch from his clue, thinking that the reference to the comic Dan Dare was in might be an extra hint. Eagle ray tooth plates [at least as far as Google images can find] don’t quite look like this so maybe I’m just trying too hard to make everything mean something [an arts degree will do that to you…]. However, I too would welcome an explanation of “fishes with piles”. The people must be told!

    • Yeah, the eagle ray was supposed to be both a guess and a clue at the same time- Turns out I was wrong, and its not the eagle ray after all.

      I too want to know what “fishes with piles” means. Could it be a reference to the tooth battery?

Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s